⏰ Tomorrow, 11 AM ET: the free workshop I had to postpone is back on. Save your seat here.
Hey Boring Marketer,
Everyone says to run creator videos. I pulled 336 live Meta ads from 48 DTC brands last week, and the ads that last are mostly stills.
Of the 34 that had been running longest (203 to 572 days), 24 are a product photo, an offer card or one line of text over a picture. Creator videos were the most tested video format, and among the first to get switched off.
How long an ad has run is the only result you can see in Meta's Ad Library. Brands switch off ads that lose money, so one still live after 200 days is probably paying for itself. By that measure, a clean still earns for months and a creator video earns for a few weeks before it needs replacing. Your first batch needs both, and most people only make the second kind.
Below is how to build that batch in five steps:
Find the ads in your category that have run 60+ days.
Pick 4 formats and 3 reasons to buy.
Make each piece with a phone, AI or a bit of code.
Write the first second.
Give each piece about 1,000 impressions before you judge it.
None of it needs a studio or a creator budget.
Step 1: Find the ads that have lasted in your category
Meta's Ad Library shows every ad running on Facebook and Instagram, and for US ads you can sort a brand's ads by impressions.
Pick 3 to 5 brands that sell what you sell (or what your client sells). Open each one, sort by impressions, and keep the ads that have run 60 days or more. An ad that old is probably paying for itself.

In my pull, 137 ads had run 60+ days. The plain product photo led by a wide margin (30 of them), then the offer card (15).
Two things will fool you. Some big spenders replace everything every two weeks (I found no Gymshark ad older than 14 days), so a brand with only young ads tells you nothing. And this close to Black Friday, offer cards crowd the list.
Selling to a local business? Pull the biggest names in that trade, local and national. A plumber's winners will look different from a coffee brand's, but the method is the same.
If you work with an agent, the free creative skill does the pull for you:
Use the creative skill to pull the live Meta ads for [3 to 5 brands that
sell what we sell], sorted by impressions. Keep the ones that have run
60+ days, look at every one, and tell me which formats and hooks they
lean on.It uses a free Firecrawl key. Without one, it gives you the Ad Library links to open yourself.
Step 2: Pick 4 formats and 3 reasons to buy
Meta now scores every eligible ad for each person before the auction even starts. Most media buyers read that as the creative doing part of the targeting. So test different formats and reasons to buy, not ten versions of one idea.

Every first batch has:
At least 4 formats, across stills and video
At least 3 angles. An angle is the reason to buy: price, speed, taste, trust.
One native piece: a phone photo that could pass for a friend's post, a customer video, or a reply to a comment
One proof piece: a real review, a before and after, or a comparison
One creator or customer video, filmed with 3 different first lines
Stills that can run for months, and videos you'll replace every few weeks
The stills that lasted longest in my pull:
Product photo. The product alone, big, on a plain background, with one line of text or none. 84 ads, 30 past 60 days.
Offer card. The offer in the biggest type, then what you get, then the terms. Hungryroot's "Get 40% off" had run 326 days.
Review quote. A real review, word for word, with the product beside it. Huel ran one reviewer's "Lost 80lbs (so far) with Huel." in three designs, two of them at 247 days.
Before and after. Only 4 ads, and all 4 had run past 60 days.
Lifestyle photo. One person with the product and one line. 6 of 7 past 60 days. Helix's man hugging a pillow had run 503 days.

For video, start with a customer-style video (8 of 18 lasted past 60 days, and the oldest ad in the whole pull is one) or a hands demo (7 of 14).
One rule for the offer card: the page it clicks to has to show the same offer. Most local business pages don't. If you want to see what a page built around one offer looks like, here's a free funnel for a local roofer.
On a small budget (under about $50 a day), start with one format and test your 3 angles in it. Add the rest once you can afford them.
Step 3: Make each piece with a phone, AI or code
Make each piece the first way the business can:
Real. The owner, staff, a customer or a creator shoots it on a phone. Vertical, window light, a clip-on mic. It's the only way to make anything that claims a customer's experience.
Model. GPT Image 2.6 for stills (it can make GIFs now too). Seedance 2.5 for short clips with natural sound. Higgsfield's Marketing Studio for presenter videos. ElevenLabs for voiceover.
Code. HTML sets every word on a still, so a misspelled word from the model never ships. HyperFrames or Remotion cut the footage together with captions and an end card.
To test all this, I made a batch for Fernwood, a made-up coffee brand, from one generated product photo. Four stills, in four formats and three angles. (Fernwood has no customers, so the reviews are placeholders.)

What I learned making it:
Make a product reference image first, and hand it to every scene and every video's first frame. The bag stayed the same across all 15 pieces.
Put the words in HTML over the picture, not inside the model. Exact words, brand fonts, no typos.
Start video from a sharp first frame, with small motion. When the bag turned mid-clip, Seedance garbled the date sticker. "Small natural handheld motion only" fixed it.
Use the built-in sound. Seedance gave us foil crinkle, beans into a grinder and a kettle pour for free.
Check the end card too. "At your door this week" got changed to "Shipped by Wednesday", because the business only promises shipping within 48 hours of roasting.
One line you don't cross: an AI presenter can demonstrate the product, but it never says it has used it and never gives a testimonial. A model never writes or credits a review either. When I tested Higgsfield's still-ad tool, 3 of its 4 ads invented something I'd told it not to: a name on a real review, a website, claims about competitors. Check every line against what's true before it ships.
With the skill, two prompts take you from plan to pieces:
Use the creative skill to plan a first Meta ad batch for [brand], from
the angles in our reviews. Follow the batch rule. For each piece give the
format, the hook, the material it needs and how we make it (real, model
or code).Use the creative skill to make pieces 1 to 4 from the batch plan,
starting with a product reference image from [product photo]. Shot
lists and creator briefs for anything we have to film.No angles yet? The positioning-angles skill finds them in your reviews first.
Step 4: Write the first second
The format is the container. The hook is what someone sees and reads in the first second, with the sound off. On a still, it's where the eye lands. On a video, it's the first frame plus the first caption.
Five openings kept showing up on ads that lasted:
The confession. "I was about to throw my Keurig away" (Atlas Coffee Club, 572 days). For anything that replaces something people already own. Real people only.
The myth or tip. "Why I never put oily beans in my espresso machine" (Atlas Coffee Club, 396 days). Every trade has a wrong way to do something.
The callout. "If you're waking up drenched, you need these" (Cozy Earth, 131 days). Name the situation, never a personal trait. Meta rejects "Are you overweight?" and accepts "Waking up drenched?"
The question. "Want brunch without the bloat?" (Lemme, 111 days). Take it from your reviews and sales calls, not from your head.
The mid-sentence caption. "Delicious coffee and it" (Trade Coffee, 109 days). Cut the first half second of breath, so the caption is already moving when the ad starts.

How to test them:
On video, film three different openings over the same body, so you're testing the hook and nothing else.
On a still, change the line or the picture, never both at once.
Use at least three different patterns in a batch, not three wordings of one.
Before a hook goes in, ask four things. Would you stop for it at 11pm, tired, thumb moving? Could ten other products run it word for word? Can you deliver what it promises? Is it as short as it can be?
Step 5: Give it 1,000 impressions, then double down
Give each piece about 1,000 impressions before you judge it, and change one thing at a time.
When something works, put more money behind the exact same file. In my pull, 120 of the 336 ads were the same creative running as two or more separate ads, up to 14 copies. Huel's "Lost 80lbs" review ran in three designs because the words worked, so they kept the words and changed the picture.
Then keep both clocks running. Leave your winning stills alone for months, and film new openings for your videos every few weeks.
The creative skill keeps score for you. When you fix something it made, it saves your fix as a yes-or-no check every later batch has to pass. After the ads run, the performance-review skill reads the results and keeps the winners as examples for the next batch.
What breaks
Trusting run time too much. Age is the best public signal, and it's still only a signal. A Black Friday card from last year was still live in my pull.
Copying the look instead of the reason. The Keurig ad works because it opens on something viewers own and are fed up with. A copy that keeps the trash can and loses that reason won't work.
Garbled text in video. Models mangle small text when things move. Start from a sharp frame, keep the motion small, and put captions on in the edit.
Words on a gradient. For a physical product, a line of text on a color isn't an ad. Show the thing.
My own blind spots. I watched 94 videos frame by frame but heard none of them, and the pull is all DTC. A plumber or a software company will see different winners, so test on your own numbers.
The oldest ad in my pull opens on a woman holding up her Keurig, captioned "I was about to throw my Keurig away". It was shot on a phone, and it had been running for 572 days when I found it.
Pick four formats and three angles, and make your batch this week.
Want the skills? The creative skill is one of 32 free skills in Boring Marketing Skills. They work in Claude Code, Codex, Cursor and other agents, for any kind of business. Install them with one line:
npx skills add boringmarketer/boring-marketing-skillsThen type /start-here and name your business.
The ad is half the job. The page it clicks to is the other half. Here's a whole funnel built for a local roofer (a sample business), from the ad to the follow-up emails.
Miscellaneous vibes
I'm open sourcing 32 of my best marketing skills for AI agents, the creative skill from this issue included
How to build a one-person million dollar agency with AI agents, the full written version
Before your Black Friday ads go live, buy from your own store on your phone and check these 4 screens
I wouldn't run a single ad until I could name my niche in one line. Ads are great at scaling a market you've already found, and a very expensive way to find one
Greg Isenberg on the stack behind an AI ad that produced $1.4M in ARR: a voice clone, Seedance for the video, an upscale and a word-for-word transcript check
Idea Browser's $1.8M/yr startup idea: IKEA hack plans as one-click kits, sold with before/after ads
From November 20, Meta's new terms make advertisers solely responsible for anything its AI features create or change in their ads
Meta's AI ad tools showed discounts that businesses had turned off. One more reason to check every line before it ships
Keep it boring
Most of the ads that ran for a year in my pull could be made with a phone, a product photo and one real review. Leaving the winner alone is the hard part.
Wanna see a whole funnel built for a local roofer (a sample business)? Get your first free funnel.
Wanna build alongside 2,500+ marketers? Join The Boring Marketing Community.
Got a question? Just hit reply. I read every message.
Know someone who makes ads for a business? Forward this to them.
Keep it boring,
James
P.S. Tomorrow (Wednesday, Nov 18) at 11 AM ET, I'm running the free workshop I had to postpone in October: How I'd Build an AI Marketing Service for Local Businesses From Scratch. Today was about the ads. Tomorrow is the whole service around them: the niche, the offer, the funnel and what to charge. It's 90 minutes on Zoom and recorded, so everyone who registers gets the replay. Signed up for the October date? Grab your spot on the new page so the link reaches you. Save your seat here.
